Monday 21 January 2013

The problem with "There"

Most of us are familiar with the subject-verb agreement rule exemplified in the sentences below:

(1) A tree is uprooted.
(2) Many trees are uprooted.

In (1), the simple subject is the singular noun tree and it agrees in number with the singular verb is. In (2), the plural subject trees agrees in number with the plural verb are.

Notice that the subject in each sentence precedes the verb, so its grammatical number is known before the verb is introduced. For this reason, it's much easier to choose the right verb.

When a sentence begins with There, we have a different subject-verb agreement order. Although There precedes the verb, it doesn't determine subject-verb agreement. Linguists call There a dummy subject:

(3) There is a tree.
(4) There are trees.

The singular verb is in (3) is determined by the singular noun tree, not by There. Similarly, the plural are in (4) is determined by the plural trees. It may be helpful to think of tree and trees in (3) and (4) respectively as delayed subjects.

Because the true subject in (3) and (4) follows the verb, it's not so obvious what verb is required. Consequently, the wrong singular verb is commonly used:

ChannelNewsAsia - 13 January 2013
The delayed subject is the plural leads, and so the correct verb is have: Law and Foreign Affairs Minister K Shanmugam said there have been some leads on the recent case of cat mutilation.

Friday 11 January 2013

Is Some singular or plural?

Does some take a singular or plural verb?

The answer depends.

Indefinite pronouns such as some can be singular or plural depending what they are referring to. With countable nouns, some requires a plural verb while with uncountable nouns, some requires a singular verb:

(1) Some books are missing.
(2) Some rice was stolen.

It doesn't matter whether some is modified by a prepositional phrase:

(3) Some of the books are missing.
(4) Some of the rice was stolen.

In the screenshot below, some refers to information, which is uncountable. The correct verb is has:

ChannelNewsAsia - 11 January 2013